How would you approach redesigning a core feature after negative user feedback?
Model answer
Model answerNegative feedback is data, not a mandate. My first step is to understand what users are actually complaining about versus what they're asking for — these are different things. If users say 'this is too complicated,' I'd watch session recordings before redesigning anything. Then I'd form a hypothesis, prototype the simplest possible fix, and test it with 10 users. I'd measure whether the redesign improves task completion rate and NPS, not just whether users say they like it.
Framework · Jobs-to-be-Done
- JClarify the real job
Separate user complaints from underlying needs - TTest before redesigning
Watch sessions, run usability tests — diagnose before prescribing - BBuild the smallest fix first
Prototype the minimal change that addresses the core complaint - DDefine success clearly
Task completion rate, NPS, support tickets — not just 'users like it'
Related questions
- How would you improve the onboarding experience for a B2B SaaS product?
- You're the PM for Instagram Stories. How would you improve it?
- How would you design a feature to reduce churn in a subscription app?
- You're the PM for a maps app. How would you improve it for cyclists?
- Design a feature that helps users discover content they didn't know they wanted.